11 Better Than Sex Mascara Dupes For A Quick Volume

Makeup and getting ready has become such an integral part of our life. It has become so important even when we step out for something casual. We do a primitive amount of makeup for any casual meet too. One of the most common items in a makeup bag is mascara. Eye makeup has many different levels, and mascara is included in them. An ideal mascara makes your eyelashes pop out and defines them well without emptying your pocket.

Most of us have a fixed mascara brand that makes our lash curls last longer and increases the volume of our eyelashes. However, new brands are constantly inventing something better than they did later. 

Better Than Sex Mascara Dupe

Too Faced is one such brand, as it has always brought something fresh and attractive. They have a Better Than Sex Mascara which, by the name itself, tells a different story. This mascara has won hearts everywhere and has done very well in the market. But, we had to search for a Better Than Sex Mascara Dupe because Too Faced has a higher price point. Thus, we picked out some great options for you to try.

Better Than Sex Mascara Dupe | Mascaras Similar to the Better Than Sex Mascara 

Better Than Sex Mascara has been regarded as the best in the US. People love this mascara for the voluminous curls and stretch that you get with each coat of mascara. The packaging of the product is fundamental but looks very classy. It has a pink signature Too Faced shade which looks very cute. The formula is also commendable, which makes the mascara what it is today.

It contains film-forming polymers that can thicken and bind your lashes. This can help keep your lashes in place and make them look more voluminous. The formula also includes a peptide. Peptides in the formula help your lashes to stay in shape and look as black as possible.

It can also condition your lashes. The unique thing about this mascara is the applicator. The applicator wand is an hourglass-shaped wand that can be very beneficial for shaping your lashes and making them last longer. The wand lifts your lashes from the bottom and ensures the whole lash is coated with the formula. It is waterproof mascara, and you don’t have to worry about getting into the water.

The mascara stays on for a long time without smudging or wearing off. The mascara only comes in a black shade, and one of the disadvantages is that there are no more shades for us to choose from. It can increase your lash volume and the appearance of your lashes. There are similar mascaras with a low price range and are as follows.

L’Oreal Paris Lash Paradise Mascara

The L’Oreal Paris Lash Paradise Mascara looks like the original Too Faced Mascara. It seems the same in terms of packaging and appearance. L’Oreal is a trustworthy brand and has always made good quality products. The only thing that you should look for in a good mascara is the applicator and the formula.

It has to be volumizing and shaping for your eyelashes. This is the primary function of mascara. The procedure has rose oil and castor oil, which can moisturize and nourish your eyelashes. 


  • The packaging looks very similar to the original product and has a lovely color. 
  • It has a very wide applicator that has more than 200 bristles. The more bristles the applicator has, the more it can define and shape you. 
  • The formula is well-made and can glide on your eyelashes easily. 
  • The mascara has a volumizing and lengthening feel to your lashes. 
  • It can coat the formula from the base to the tip of your lashes. 
  • The mascara does not flake, smudge, or clump on your lashes. 
  • It gives a volumizing and thickening effect on your lashes. 
  • The mascara has long-staying power, and it does not smudge away quickly. 
  • It is waterproof too. 
  • The application process is easy, and anyone can do it quickly. 

Better Than Sex Mascara Dupe


  • It can irritate your eyelashes which can be a big worry.
  • Some reviews say that they don’t like the smell of the mascara. 
  • According to reviews, it can also make your lashes sticky. 

Maybelline the Falsies Lash Lift Washable Mascara 

Maybelline is a brand that has been in the market long enough to understand the products. They have many mascaras, but the Falsies Lash Lift mascara is the fittest as a Better Than Sex Mascara dupe for the original mascara.

The mascara has been loved for making your eyelashes look voluminous and thicker than before. It has a fiber-infused formula that helps your lashes to stay in place for a long time. There is only one color in the mascara, like the original one: black. 


  • The packaging of the mascara is attractive as it has a steel look. It is not very innovative, but it is good enough for the mascara. 
  • The applicator wand is the same as the original mascara. It has an hourglass shape that can be very beneficial for defining your lashes. It makes you coat your lashes from the base to the top. 
  • It comes in three shades: blackest black, ultra black, and very black.
  • This lifting mascara can volumize your lashes and make them look twice the size. 
  • It can visibly improve the appearance of your lashes by lifting them and making them look like falsies, as defined by their name. 
  • The formula does not flake, smudge, or stick your lashes. 
  • It is cheaper than the original product. 

Better Than Sex Mascara Dupe


  • According to some reviews, it can be very liquid in its form. 
  • Some women found the wand to be too thick. 
  • It can be a little drying and can clump some of my lashes. 
  • Even if the product is very cheap, some women don’t feel the mascara is worth it. 

Essence Lash Princess False Effect Mascara 

Essence Cosmetics looks like a teenage girl brand for cosmetics. However, the effects and results of their mascara are very similar to the original mascara. If you look at the appearance of the mascara, you might think this is lipstick. However, there are different mascaras that Essence has.

The one with black and green writing is the one that we are looking for. The primary aim of this mascara is very similar to the rest of the mascara as it increases the volume of your lashes and makes them look thicker. It may not look like a product that can deliver such excellent results, but the reviews are entirely for the mascara, let’s see how. 


  • The packaging looks very funky and friendly. It looks very different from the original pink packaging but is still attractive. 
  • The applicator is not similar to the Too Faced mascara as it does not have an hourglass shape but something very similar to it. 
  • It increases the volume of your lashes and makes them look bushier than ever. 
  • You need about 2-3 coats of formula for your lashes for a compelling hold on your lashes. 
  • The lasting power of the mascara is excellent. It can stay on your lashes for almost an entire day. 
  • It does not flake, clump, or smudge on your lashes. 
  • It separates lashes and makes them look longer and thicker individually. 
  • This is cheaper than the original product. 

Better Than Sex Mascara Dupe


  • Some reviews say that it can be itchy on your skin, and it may feel sticky after some time. 
  • There was a lot of clumping and flaking that resulted from the use of the mascara. 
  • The formula is dehydrated to have a strong hold on your lashes. 

Rimmel Scandaleyes Mascara 

Rimmel is another makeup brand with tremendous experience delivering what customers desire. Their mascara looks very modern and funky. It has neon orange-colored packaging and looks great. We instantly know that whatever is going to come out of this will is going to look amazing on your lashes.

Something about the packaging speaks volumes about the product’s effect on your eyelashes. The function of the lashes is to increase the volume of your lashes and make them look darker. 


  • It has a funky color and appearance in terms of the packaging. It is desirable and makes you want something of this color in your makeup bag. 
  • The applicator wand is not very similar to the original mascara. It does not have an hourglass structure but a simple bristle structure. 
  • It comes in two colors, namely black and extreme black. 
  • The mascara can give volume to your lashes and make them look thick. 
  • This is a long-wear mascara, and it can stay for an entire day. 
  • It does not smudge, flake or clump on your eyelashes. 
  • The mascara is cheaper than the original mascara. 


  • Some reviews say that there is an excess product on the applicator, and you always apply more. 
  • There can be some clumping and stickiness on your lashes. 

Covergirl Flamed Out Mascara 

Covergirl Flamed Out mascara can be a good choice for you if you want other shades in the mascara. They can make your eyelashes look voluminous and thicker than before. This does not cause any hair breakage or stiffness in hair.

The mascara looks more like lipstick. The packaging does not look very appealing but has many perks. It comes in more than one shade, giving us an edge. It can make your eyelashes look thicker and more voluminous. 


  • The packaging of the mascara is fundamental and very affordable mascara. 
  • It comes in four shades: black blaze, black blaze, black-brown blaze, and brown blaze. 
  • The mascara can increase the volume of your eyelash hair and make them look thicker. 
  • It has a suitable applicator that can lift your lashes and ensure that the whole of your lash can be coated with the formula. 
  • The mascara’s staying power is good and can last a long time. 
  • It is waterproof, and you need not stay out of the water. 


  • The packaging is very cheap, and there could be an improvement in that sector. It comes in actual plastic packaging that looks more like a drugstore product. 
  • The applicator wand does not have a perfect shape and does not lift your lashes as well as it should. 
  • It can dry out your eyelash hair and make it a little clumpy. 

NYX Worth the Hype Mascara 

NYX makes the best Better Than Sex Mascara Dupe for the most expensive product. They have made a fantastic effort with that one. It has black packaging, which looks very decent and friendly.

It has a buildable formula, and you can choose the amount of product you want to get on your lashes. It is an actual product, but it works wonders. There are many positive reviews about the formula and the mascara results. 


  • The packaging of the mascara is fundamental, but it does look attractive. 
  • It has an hourglass-shaped applicator that can apply the formula evenly on your eyelashes. 
  • Your lashes look more voluminous and thicker than before. 
  • Eyelashes don’t feel stiff or wide, but they feel very soft after applying the formula.
  • It has a waterproof formula; you need not stay out of the water after application. 
  • There is no clumping, flaking, or stickiness involved. 
  • The application process is easy, and it does not take much knowledge to apply. 


  • The waterproof nature is not very prominent, and some reviews say it doesn’t work. 
  • There is terrible smudging of the formula and some clumping as well. 

Covergirl Exhibitionist Stretch and Strengthen Mascara 

Covergirl has another mascara that is very similar to the original product. It is a basic mascara, but the results are excellent. The primary aim of this mascara is volumizing and making your eyelashes look bolder. 


  • The packaging looks pretty subtle and pleasant. It has a nice silver monotone color as the packaging. 
  • It has a very thickening and volumizing effect on your lashes. 
  • There is only one color available, and it is a black shade. 
  • This is a waterproof formula; you can attend pool parties without guilt. 
  • It has a long staying power and will stay for an entire day. 
  • The mascara can be applied easily without difficulty and does not clump/ flake or stick to your lashes. 
  • It does not smudge easily and stays on for a long time. 
  • The removal process is not a hassle; it can come off very quickly. 
  • One or two coats are enough. 


  • Some customers had an issue with the removal process of the mascara. 
  • Some women were irritated with the brush as the formula did not go on evenly. 

Wet N Wild Max Volume Plus Waterproof Mascara 

Wet N Wild has another addition to the waterproof mascara range. The packaging of this mascara is not that impressive. It looks fundamental, and they could do better in this sector. The color looks pretty girly. It has a good formula, made for volumizing your eyelashes.


  • It has actual packaging, and the applicator wand is easy to use. 
  • This has a well-pigmented black formula that makes your eyelashes look thicker. 
  • The formula also contains vitamin E for moisturization. 
  • It can soften your eyelashes and give them a good definition. 
  • You can get longer, voluminous, and blacker-looking eyelashes the next day. 
  • They are water-resistant, humidity-resistant, and smudge resistant. 
  • The formula does not flake and clump on your lashes. 


  • Some women say that the formula they received was dry and clumpy on their eyelashes. 
  • The removal process of this mascara is not easy. 
  • It can feel clumpy and sticky on your lashes. 

e.l.f Big Mood Mega Volume and Lifting Mascara 

The Big Mood Mascara sounds very bold and thick by the name itself. Elf is an old and trustworthy brand. They can make excellent quality products in the affordable price range making it the best Better Than Sex Mascara Dupe. This product’s packaging is very impressive; they have chic and new-age packaging with this mascara. It is one of the best-rated mascaras available.


  • It comes in a blue metallic shade with the applicator. 
  • The mascara applicator is an hourglass shape and can apply the formula from the base to your lash at the tip. 
  • The mascara volumizes and makes your lashes look much thicker. 
  • It can plump and lift your lashes like falsies. 
  • This has a waterproof formula. 
  • The mascara has a soft and creamy effect to it. 
  • It has a smudge-free and flake-free formula. 


  • Some users say it does flake and smudge during the day. 
  • The formula can be a little thick and clumpy if you get excess. 
  • According to some reviews, they did not find the applicator user-friendly and too gigantic for application. 
  • The formula can become a little clumpy after a week or so. 

Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara 

Honest Beauty is a slightly more expensive brand than the other dupes. It has a mascara that can also be used as a primer for your eyelashes. This has become a cult classic, and we must agree because they have all the right reasons.

The formula contains jojoba esters which are responsible for all the magic. The mascara provides an excellent lift to your eyelashes and makes them look very voluminous. 


  • The packaging looks very basic but stylish. Honest Beauty has always been minimal with packaging. 
  • The mascara can volumize your eyelashes and make them look bolder or thicker. 
  • Your eyelashes look more defined. 
  • You can use this formula as a base or primer for your mascara. 
  • The primer base can enhance your mascara’s stopping power and quality. 
  • It also boosts the length and defines each lash. 
  • The staying power is good, and the mascara is waterproof too. 


  • The consistency of the formula can be a little weird. 
  • It needs some time for the removal process. 
  • It can clump and flake if you get excess on. 
  • This is a little more expensive than the other options and similar to the original product. 

Burt’s Bee Natural Origin Mascara 

Burt’s Bee has a unique formula for its mascara. It has jojoba oil and glycerin in the formula. These can be nourishing and moisturizing for your lashes. The packaging does not seem very impressive, but the formula is worth it. 


  • The applicator has an hourglass shape and can ensure the even application of the formula. 
  • The packaging is minimal, and it is black. 
  • It comes in only one color, black. 
  • It can volumize your lashes and make them look even thicker. 


  • This product can smudge a lot. 
  • Some reviews claim that the new formula might have changed as they have never noticed these clumps. 


We were looking for a Better Than Sex Mascara Dupe and found multiple options. Some mascaras have a similar formula and wand applicator. The shape of the wand and the bristles on it matter a lot when shaping your eyebrows. Always look for waterproof and long-wear mascara. Check their formula for ingredients and ensure you are not using an expired product when it arrives. 

You need to apply just the right amount of mascara as it may get clumpy because of using excess. Mascara can elevate the look of your face and make your eyes look bolder. Using mascara daily is fine, but you must choose a skin-friendly one. The application and removal process needs to be user-friendly too. Waterproof mascaras reduce anxiety about getting in the pool or during a hot day. 

Found the read insightful? Here’s more for you:


Leave a Comment