11 Mac Spice Lip Liner Dupes | Affordable & Pigmented Choices

Lipsticks make our faces look bolder, and they elevate the look of our faces. Lipstick is not the only thing that can make your face look better. It is the fact that they sit perfectly on your lips and enhance the shape of your lips. They make them appear sharp and wide. Lip liners are the key to having perfect lips. They come in different shades and make your lips look more defined. The key to having the ideal lip liner is that it is supposed to be creamy and well pigmented. Many companies can make a good lip liner, but shade matters a lot here.

Mac Spice Lip Liner Dupe

Finding the perfect shade is not difficult to find now. Mac makes one of the best lip liners and has stunning shades. They are made well and can be considered one of the best in the market. Their Spice shade in the lip liner range is worth finding a Mac Spice Lip Liner Dupe. The reason for not finding a dupe is that the Mac Liner is expensive. 

Mac Spice Lip Liner Dupe | 11 Affordable Options

Mac Spice Lip Liner is one of the best products, and the range has been a bestseller. The lip liner is fantastic, and it has many shades. In this case, the Spice shade is all we care about. It comes in 19 shades. The spice shade is a warm brown shade which is neither brown nor nude. It looks very subtle and mild on your lips. You can shape, line, and also fill in your lips. You can use the liner in multiple ways and get a lot of use.

Sale
M.A.C Lip Pencil, Spice, 1 Count
  • item package length: 2.032cm
  • item package width: 3.81cm
  • item package height: 15.494cm
  • model number: 773602002160
  • Skin type: Combination

Some of the primary ingredients in the lip liner are Japan Fruit Wax and vegetable oil. They are skin-friendly and nourishing so that they won’t harm your skin. The formula is creamy and matte. You can apply the liner easily without much effort.

The liner has a fantastic texture and feels comfortable on your lips. The liner is formulated without harmful chemicals like mineral oil, coal tar, triclosan, toluene, silicone, and paraben. It can make your lips look more defined and sharp. The only disadvantage of the liner is the price point. It might be worth the price for people, but not everyone can afford it. These are the dupes for Mac Spice Liner. Compare the shade and choose the one you feel is the closest. 

NYX Professional Lip Liner Peekaboo Neutral

NYX can be considered a pro for making similar products in a lower price range. The best thing about them is that they don’t compromise on quality. These liners come in a natural lip pencil form and are long-lasting on your lips. It comes in many shades. They are made to give your lips a definite shape and make them look sharp.

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Slim Lip Pencil, Long-Lasting Creamy Lip Liner - Peakaboo Neutral
  • Lip Liner In All Shades: NYX Professional Makeup Slim Lip Pencil natural lip liner pencils come in a variety of dashing shades from auburn to orange and traffic stopping red to line and define your lips
  • Long Wearing Lip Liner Pencil: This buttery soft, long wearing lip pencil formula goes on easily and resists bleeding; Glide it on for an instant pump to your pout accompanying your favorite NYX Professional Makeup lipsticks and lip glosses
  • Lip Products for the Perfect Pout: Doll your lips in creamy, long lasting perfection; Try our complete line of lip makeup including liquid lipstick, lip gloss, lip cream, lip liner and butter gloss
  • Cruelty Free Cosmetics: We believe animals belong in our arms, not in a lab; All of our makeup is certified and acknowledged by PETA as a cruelty free brand; We don't test any of our products on animals
  • Discover NYX Professional Makeup: Try all of our professional makeup products today from eyeshadow, eyeliner, and false lashes to liquid lipstick, lip gloss, primer, concealer, setting sprays and eyebrow makeup

The liner has a creamy and satin finish when applied to your lips. Peekaboo Neutral shade is the classic brown for which the Mac Liner is known. This is one of the cheapest options on the list of dupes. 

Benefits 

  • It has a smooth and creamy textured formula. 
  • It has clean ingredients and does not irritate your skin. 
  • The lip liner has a fantastic texture and does not drag or skip. 
  • The application process is easy and does not take much time. 
  • It also does not bleed on your lips. 
  • All the colors are coordinated, and you can easily find your desired shade. 
  • Most of the colors are similar to the original product. 
  • You can also multi-task and use it on your eyelids. It means that you can use it for your eye makeup. 
  • The liner is highly pigmented and blendable. 
  • It is also a long-wearing lip liner and stays for a long time. 
  • It has a matte finish and blends well with your lipstick. 
  • The liner is also affordable. 

Mac Spice Lip Liner Dupe

Drawbacks 

  • It may not work and look great on dark women. This is a lighter shade and might not look good on darker women. 

Mented Cosmetics Nude Lip Liner Pencil 

Mented Cosmetics has been doing quite well and making good quality products too. They also have a range of pigmented lip liners. The lip liners are waterproof, and the formula is very well made. They are creamy and pigmented in nature, making them perfect for quick application.

Mented Cosmetics La La Nude Lip Liner Pencil, Waterproof Lip Liner Nude Lip Pencil, Natural Lip Liner Nude Lip Vegan and Cruelty-Free Makeup, Matte Lip Liners for Women, Makeup for Black Women
  • Natural Waterproof Lip Liner: This Natural lip liner glides across the lips for natural-looking definition that lasts. Our long-lasting lip liners are made with a creamy formula and buttery texture while being highly pigmented to provide for over 8 hours of wear.
  • Full Coverage Nude: This Nude Lip Liner Pencil is a sophisticated deep pink with a brown undertone. Pair this neutral pencil lipstick liner with Mented’s Nude Lala Semi Matte Lipstick! This combination is the perfect pink for darker lips, providing full coverage nude. Wear it to work meetings or just to glam up for some selfies. This nude makeup brightens your smile.
  • Made From Safe Ingredients - These lip liners for women are made with safe ingredients. Our lip liners are vegan, non-toxic, and paraben-free.
  • Cruelty Free Lip Liner - Going cruelty-free is better for you and for the planet. Our lip liner did not undergo animal testing. This is not only good for the animals but also for your overall health. Support an amazing ethical cause by purchasing cruelty-free products like Mented Cosmetics.
  • Universally Flattering - created by black women, celebrating all hues. Mented products are guaranteed to flatter any complexion of any hue.

The pencil also blends well with your lipstick and gives it an excellent definition. The Nude shade which is corresponding to the Mac Spice liner. It looks very similar, and it has a tan color. It does not have a completely matte finish but a semi-matte finish. 

Pros 

  • It is a long-lasting lip liner and stays on your lips for about 8 hours. 
  • The liner is waterproof and repels water. 
  • The application process is straightforward. 
  • It is creamy and feels buttery on your lips. 
  • The shade looks pretty on all complexions and works for all skin types. 
  • Vegan product 
  • Non-toxic and paraben-free product 
  • The texture of the pencil is slidable and does not form blots. 

Cons 

  • The waterproof nature of the lipstick is not for a long time. It will come off when you’re eating or drinking. However, the reapplication process is much easier. 
  • The original shade of the lipstick looks much different than in the picture. It is a little darker than the picture. However, it looks great. 

Mirabella Lip Definer Pencil Flirty 

Mirabella is another lesser-known brand doing very well in the sector. The packaging of the liner looks fantastic and has a steel look. The color of the lip liner is on the bottom, and that’s how you identify them. The most similar shade to the Mac Spice is the flirty shade. It is the best Mac Spice Lip Liner Dupe.

Mirabella Lip Definer Pencil, Flirty - Retractable Line & Define Lip Liner with Sharpener - Long-Lasting, & Ultra-Creamy Formula with Vitamin C & E is Smoothing & Moisturizing - Gluten & Cruelty-Free
  • Mirabella Line and Define Retractable Lip Definer: Creamy liner formula glides onto lips for flawless all-day wear while the retractable pencil allows for effortless application. The built-in sharpener on the base allows for ease of use on the go! Color: Flirty
  • Natural Lip Line: Precise lip-lining pencil with amazing texture. Created to provide a barrier around the perimeter of lips, each liner works to prevent lipstick and gloss from feathering or bleeding.
  • Improved Packaging and Formula: Now featuring a retractable pencil with built-in sharpener while the new long-wear formula features an ultra-creamy feel that glides on smoothly.
  • No “No-No’s”: Paraben-free, gluten-free, cruelty-free.
  • Beauty is a Lifestyle: Mirabella was created by makeup artists for beauty enthusiasts and professionals alike. Our mineral-based cosmetic line is full of clean products with quality formulas, so you can feel safe putting them on your skin. For professional or at-home use.

Flirty may not look like the right shade on paper, but you should see the swatches. It looks very different from the original color. It might look pinker than the original brownish shade. The swatch can explain it all to you. The liner also has an in-built sharpener. It has a creamy and pigmented formula. 

Positives 

  • The application process is straightforward as it glides on your skin. 
  • It also has an in-built sharpener which can be used for sharpening the tip. 
  • The liner does not bleed or feather on your lips. 
  • The end of the liner is precise, and you can have a sharp lip line with the same. 
  • It is a long-wear lip liner, and you can keep it on for hours. 
  • This is a paraben and gluten-free product. 
  • Cruelty-free 
  • The liner contains vitamins E and C. 
  • This makes it moisturizing and nourishing for your skin. 
  • The packaging is beautiful. 

Negatives 

  • It still seems a bit pricey.

Rimmel Lasting Finish Lip Liner Spice 

Rimmel London is one of the best brands for buying makeup products. The lip pencil has incredible staying power and can remain on your lips for 8 hours. The packaging of the liner does not look very appealing or basic. Even if it seems fundamental, this is one of the best-rated lip pencils. It comes in many shades, a total of 14.

Sale
Rimmel Lasting Finish 8HR Lip Liner, 110 Spice, Pack of 1
  • Gliding Texture
  • Long wear
  • Precise application
  • Blends seamlessly

We are only concerned about the Spice shade identical to the original product. The texture of the liner is very creamy and pigmented.  

Pros 

  • The fantastic brand has been rated one of the best lip liners. 
  • It has a sharp tip and gives your lips a good definition. 
  • The pencil’s staying power is 8 hours. 
  • It can blend well with your lipstick, 
  • The formula has a very creamy texture and easily glides on your lips. 
  • It has a sharp tip which can make the precision fantastic. 
  • The application process is straightforward, and it does not need much instruction. 
  • It is cheap and affordable. 

Cons 

  • The color of the shade does not resemble what is shown in the picture. 
  • Some customers say it does not stay as long as they want it to.
  • There are some liners which arrived with a broken tip. 

Colourpop Beeper Lip Pencil 

Colourpop is another excellent brand that makes good quality products. They have a range of lippie pencils which come in 40 different shades. The Beeper brown shade is all we care about. It is very similar to the original lip pencil. This is a slightly thicker lip pencil. It comes with a sharpener and can sharpen the tip whenever you want a sharper outline.

Colourpop Lippie Pencil (Beeper)
  • A beautiful greige grey beige rose shade

One of the best things about this pencil is that there are so many shades that it comes in. The pencil doesn’t just form the design, but it can also fill in your lips. It sounds like a lot of work, but it seems doable when you can use one product for multiple things. 

Positives 

  • This is a long-wear lippie pencil, and it is intensely pigmented. 
  • It glides on easily and makes it feel comfortable on your lips. 
  • The pencil is easy to apply and can be used for multiple things. 
  • You can use it as a lip liner and also a lipstick. 
  • The formula is creamy and has a matte finish. 
  • It is highly pigmented and can draw a sharp line. 
  • The application process is easy. 
  • It comes with a sharpener for better usability. 

Negatives 

  • There is not much information about the negatives. 
  • But it works as a great lipstick and not a great lip liner. 

Revlon Lip Liner Nude 

Revlon is another brand that can make great quality products. You can describe this lip liner as a lush and long-lasting lip liner. These liners have a very different packaging as, unlike the others, all the colors have an individual color similar to the shade you have chosen. Others have standard black or white colored packaging.

Sale
Lip Liner by Revlon, Colorstay Face Makeup with Built-in-Sharpener, Longwear Rich Lip Colors, Smooth Application, 630 Nude
  • RICH COLOR & DEFINITION FOR FULL LIPS: Our cult-classic ColorStay lip liner provides lasting color to help your lipstick stay on longer and lips look fuller
  • LONGWEARING LIP COLOR: You get gorgeous, long lasting lip color that stays on for up to 8 hours after application without re-applying
  • HELPS PREVENT BLEEDING & FEATHERING: There’s no bleeding or feathering with Revlon lip liner, just longwear color with a smooth and lush finish
  • BUILT-IN SHARPENER: This lip pencil comes with a built-in sharpener, so you don’t have to look for extra tools on the go
  • 14 BEAUTIFUL SHADES: Find the lip liner that fits your look, with 14 colors to choose from. Pair with Revlon Super Lustrous Lipstick for a rich and lush lip look

The UI of the pencil is very user-friendly as you can roll the base to extend the lip pencil. This makes it very easy to apply the pencil. The nude shade is much similar to the original Mac lip pencil. 

Pros 

  • The lip liner has a highly pigmented and very creamy formula. 
  • It is a long-wear lip liner that stays on for a long time. 
  • It does not bleed or feather on the boundary of your lips. 
  • The liner also has a built-in sharpener. 
  • The lip liner is also easy to use. 
  • It has attractive packaging and comes in many colors. 
  • Affordable. 
  • Your lips are more defined and sharp. 
  • It can almost stay on your lips for 8 hours. 

Cons 

  • The liner is not waterproof or smudge-proof. It will start to come out as soon as you get some water near it. 
  • Some of the products arrived broken and had to be returned. 
  • The stick is very soft, and the shaft breaks easily. 
  • It could be more pigmented as it is a little dull in color. 

NARS Lip Liner Hyeres 

Nars is another pioneer brand that makes impeccable products. They also have a velvet matte lip pencil range, and the Hyeres is the perfect liner we need. This is a very thick pencil, and it can be used as a lipstick other than a lip liner. You can use the sharpened tip as the liner and use it to fill your lips too.

NARS Precision lip liner - hyeres by nars for women - 0.04 oz lip liner, 0.04 Ounce
  • A highly pigmented wooden lip liner pencil that sharply defines lips with smooth, comfortable, budge-proof, laser-focus precision
  • Highly pigmented matte color glides on smoothly to create shape
  • Definition and various lip effects

It comes in about 29 shades for you to choose from. It has a velvety matte finish, and the formula is very creamy. This is a bestseller and has a long-lasting effect on your skin, thus, is considered the best Mac Spice Lip Liner Dupe.

Positives 

  • The lip liner is creamy and satin-finish in texture. 
  • It contains Vitamin E and emollients. This can be hydrating and can give the lip pencil a creamy texture. 
  • It is long-lasting and stays on your lips for hours. 
  • The lip pencil is not just made for lip lining, as the tapered end can be used for lining and shaping. Another reason is that you can also use it to fill your lips. 
  • It can be used for blending your lipstick too. 
  • It provides medium to full coverage on your lips. 
  • The liner can make your lips feel fresh. 
  • The liner can be applied quickly, and it is convenient for you. 

Negatives 

  • Some users say that the pencil does not last for a long time. 
  • Some users expected a bigger size of the pencil for the price. 
  • The tip is sensitive and may break off if you apply too much pressure. 

Huda Beauty Warm Brown Lip Pencil 

Huda Beauty is one of the best brands for buying any kind of beauty product. The price point of the Huda Lip Liner and the original Mac Liner is almost the same. There are 12 shades in the range, and the warm brown shade is similar to the spice shade. The packaging is very appealing, and it looks fantastic.

Huda Beauty Lip Contour 2.0 Automatic Matte Lip Pencil (Warm Brown)
  • A matte lip pencil with a retractable tip and ultra-glide formula that effortlessly defines your lips.

Most of the shades are nude, and the packaging is the same as the lip pencil color. People love the packaging a lot as it also looks very classy. The liner also comes with a mini sharpener; you can sharpen the liner’s tip whenever you want a thinner line. 

Benefits 

  • The liner is creamy and feels buttery soft on your lips. 
  • It is easy to use. 
  • The sharpener makes it very comfortable for us to have a sharp tip for lining our lips. 
  • It is long-lasting and stays on your lips for almost 6 hours. 
  • The liner has a matte finish, and it can blend your lipstick. 
  • They also call it the automatic lip pencil. 
  • One of the best advantages is that it’s waterproof. 

Drawbacks 

  • There are no negative reviews for this product, as everyone loves it. 

Wet N Wild Lip Liner Brown 

Wet N Wild is well-known for making good quality products at affordable prices. They also have a range of lip liners and about 6 shades. The brown lip liner can be a great Mac Spice Lip Liner Dupe. The packaging is fundamental again, and it is not very impressive.

Lip Liner Pencil By Wet n Wild Color Icon Lip Color Makeup, Dark Brown Chestnut
  • This rich, creamy formula glides on silky-smooth and makes sure your lip color doesnt bleed so youll always have a well-defined pout
  • Makeup artists love to use this as a lipstick, applying it all over the lips
  • They last longer and make sure you're not rocking that early 90s two-toned lip!

Despite the low price point, the formula is fantastic, and many women can vouch for it. Although it looks like a thin lip liner, it can also be used for filling in your lips. You can use it to blend your lipstick. This is regarded as the multi-purpose nature of the pencil. 

Positives 

  • The formula is creamy in texture and feels very smooth on your skin. 
  • It does not bleed on your lips and can define your lips’ boundaries. 
  • It can also be used for filling in your lips. 
  • The liner can stay for a long time on your lips and not create a mess. 
  • They are a cruelty-free brand.  
  • Active ingredients like Vitamin E and soy extract can nourish and hydrate your lips. 
  • The liner is highly pigmented and looks prominent on your lips. 
  • It can also be perfect for blending your lipstick. 

Negatives

  • It can be very drying for your lips. 
  • Some say it is not for dark-skinned women as it is very bright, even in the darkest shade. 

Kat Von D in Lolita 

Kat Von D is another brand that is very famous for producing good quality products. The packaging of the product is attractive and has an opaque covering. It has a design in the middle, and it is plain otherwise. The liner comes in many colors, but Lolita is a pretty shade corresponding to the original Mac lip liner.

Kat Von D Everlasting Liquid Lipstick - LOLITA ll
  • Kat Von D Everlasting Liquid Lipstick - LOLITA ll-terra cotta nude
  • FULL SIZE 0.22 oz/ 6.6 mL

It can also be very comfortable to wear all day long. The lip liner was one of their best-selling products. They can make up for almost all the blendable shades for your lipsticks. 

Benefits 

  • The liner feels natural on your skin and comfortable to wear for a long time. 
  • The texture and the creamy nature of the lip pencil can be very easy for the applicant as it glides on your skin. 
  • Because of the creamy texture, you don’t need to drag and skip the liner on your lips.  
  • The formula is very well pigmented and immediately dries down. 
  • Vegan product 
  • Cruelty-free 
  • It is easy to use, and you tend not to make a mess. 

Drawbacks 

  • The price point is very close to the original product. Instead, we do not think about this as we can end up spending the same amount. 
  • Some users say that the quality of the liner is very cheap and can break easily. 

Kiss New York Warm Brown Lip Liner 

Kiss New is a lesser-known brand but looks similar to the original product. The formula is well formulated, and it has an easy-to-use UI. It has a retractable tip and can easily make a creamy boundary on your lips.

Kiss New York Luxury Intense Lip Liner, Long-Lasting Creamy Lip Liner Retractable Easy to Use Lip Liner (1 Count, Brown)
  • Retractable Lip Liner
  • A smooth, glide-on, non-drying formula
  • Build-able texture that is creamy and silky smooth
  • Can be used to outline lips or fully colored in

The structure makes it easy for us to apply the liner. It comes in about 12 shades, and their warm brown lip liner is the shade for us. They have more pop colors, but basic shades and brown is one of them. 

Pros 

  • The formula used is buildable and can also use to fill your lips a little.
  • It is creamy and well pigmented. 
  • This makes it very easy for us to blend our lipstick. 
  • The texture of the stick is smooth and glides on your skin. 
  • Some women consider this a luxury lip liner.  
  • It is very cheap and affordable. 
  • There are packs of 3, and you can buy them in multiples. 
  • You can also use it for filling in your lips. 

Mac Spice Lip Liner Dupe

Cons 

  • The liner’s tip is very sensitive and can break from time to time. 
  • The application process is much easier, but there are still women who complain about the application. 

Closure 

The Mac Spice Liner is one of a kind because it has a creamy texture, and it’s made with good quality ingredients. We did not have much difficulty finding a Mac Spice Lip Liner Dupe. We found multiple dupes that are very similar to the original product. All you need to look for is the color which is a nude brown. The formula should be long-wearing and highly pigmented. It is a plus point if the liner is waterproof.

Your lipstick should blend well with the liner, and the Mac Spice is a shade that can integrate with all the lipstick shades. Lip liners are essential when we want our lips to look flawless on occasion. They give a definite shape to our lips and make them look bolder. 

Leave a Comment